Training a dog is a rewarding journey that strengthens the bond between human and canine. However, not all dog breeds are created equal when it comes to obedience and learning. Some breeds present unique challenges, making them particularly daunting for even the most experienced owners. In “7 Hardest Dog Breeds to Train for the Experienced Owner,” we delve into the complexities of these stubborn yet fascinating breeds. From inherent independence to high energy levels and stubborn streaks, these dogs require patience, consistency, and unique strategies. Discover which breeds make the list and how their distinct characteristics can turn training into a true test of skill and dedication.
Thinking about adding a new furry friend to your home but want to avoid training headaches? You’re in the right place. While every dog has its unique charm, some breeds come with a reputation for being a bit more challenging to train—a factor worth considering, especially if you’re a first-time dog owner.
Training is a crucial part of building a happy, harmonious life with your dog. However, some breeds are known for their strong-willed, independent nature, making it more difficult to teach basic commands. These pups aren’t untrainable by any means, but they require an owner who is patient, consistent, and willing to put in the extra effort to bring out the best in them.
If you’re up for the challenge, these dogs can become fiercely loyal and deeply rewarding companions. So, let’s dive into the world of the hardest dog breeds to train and explore what makes them unique and lovable despite their stubborn streaks!
How Is Trainability Measured?
When it comes to labeling a dog breed as “hard to train,” certain measurable traits play a crucial role. The concept of trainability isn’t arbitrary—it’s based on specific behavioral qualities that indicate how well a dog learns and follows instructions. One widely recognized tool for assessing these traits is the Canine Behavioral Assessment and Risk Questionnaire (C-BARQ). This questionnaire evaluates several factors that collectively determine a dog’s trainability, including:
-
Quick Learning Ability: How fast a dog grasps new concepts or tasks.
-
Response to Correction: Whether a dog adjusts its behavior appropriately after being corrected.
-
Focus Amid Distractions: The dog’s ability to stay on task despite external stimuli.
-
Obedience to Simple Commands: Willingness to follow basic instructions like “sit” or “stay.”
-
Fetching Willingness: Enthusiasm for retrieving objects during training or play.
-
Listening to Trainers: How receptive the dog is to instruction and guidance.
Breeds that naturally excel in these areas are generally easier to train, while those that struggle with one or more of these traits may require more time, patience, and effort from their owners.
7 Hardest Dog Breeds to Train
1. Beagle
Beagles, adored for their compact size, intelligence, and gentle temperament, are also known for being one of the more difficult breeds to train. As scent hounds originally bred for tracking and hunting small game, Beagles have an extraordinary sense of smell that often takes precedence over their focus during training sessions. Their powerful noses make them easily distracted, turning even a simple command into a challenge.
Unlike more obedient breeds, Beagles have a stubborn streak and a strong instinct to follow scent trails, making them less inclined to listen to commands, especially in outdoor settings. Despite their training difficulties, Beagles are fantastic family pets and are particularly great with kids. However, their natural hunting instincts and focus on smells can make recall training and off-leash behavior tricky.
Training Tip
The good news is that Beagles are highly food-motivated, which can be a big advantage during training. Using high-value treats as rewards can help capture their attention and encourage them to learn new skills and good behavior more effectively. Patience, consistency, and plenty of tasty rewards are key to training this lovable yet determined breed.
2. Border Collie
Border Collies are renowned for their exceptional intelligence, often regarded as the smartest dog breed and their unwavering loyalty. Originally bred to herd sheep across the vast landscapes of Scotland and England, these dogs have boundless energy and a strong drive to work. While their intelligence makes them quick learners, their high energy levels and need for a job can make training a bit of a challenge. Without proper outlets, Border Collies may channel their energy into undesirable behaviors, such as being destructive or overly obsessive.
Their instinct to stay busy means they thrive in environments where they have plenty of mental and physical stimulation. Training them requires not just patience but also a structured routine that balances their need for exercise with their quick learning ability.
Training Tip: To set your Border Collie up for success, ensure they get plenty of exercise and stimulation daily. Activities like agility training, running, or backpacking are excellent outlets for their energy. Keep training sessions short, engaging, and filled with variety to capture their attention and harness their incredible potential.
3. Alaskan Malamute
The Alaskan Malamute is a strikingly beautiful dog, often compared to the Husky, but don’t let their looks fool you—they are one of the most challenging breeds to train. Bred for cold climates and hard work, Malamutes are incredibly loyal and independent, but that independence often comes with a stubborn streak and a high prey drive. Their dominant nature can make them difficult to handle, especially for inexperienced owners.
Unlike many other breeds, Malamutes are not easily motivated by treats or praise, which can make training particularly challenging. Their northern breed instincts require a confident and firm owner who understands how to set boundaries and assert leadership effectively. Without this, a Malamute may ignore commands altogether.
Training Tip
For Malamutes, professional training is often a must. Focus on early socialization and consistent boundaries, and prepare for ongoing work to curb their dominant and willful tendencies. Patience, confidence, and a structured approach will help manage this magnificent but challenging breed.
4. Bloodhound
Bloodhounds, much like Beagles, are celebrated for their incredible sense of smell, which makes them unparalleled hunting and tracking dogs. However, this remarkable trait also makes them one of the hardest breeds to train. When a Bloodhound catches a scent, their entire focus shifts to following the trail, often ignoring commands or abandoning a training session altogether. Their instincts to pursue scents are so strong that they are widely used in law enforcement to locate missing persons or fugitives.
While Bloodhounds are intelligent, their independent and stubborn nature can make standard training methods ineffective. They require a patient and experienced trainer who understands their unique personality and utilizes consistent positive reinforcement. These dogs are not ideal for inexperienced owners or those seeking a quiet companion, as they can be loud and have poor recall.
Training Tip
Bloodhounds thrive when persistence and positive reinforcement are used during training. Though challenging, their keen sense of smell and independent streak can be guided into making them affectionate, loyal companions. With the right approach, these determined scent hounds can excel in specialized roles and bring immense joy to their owners.
5. Basset Hound
Known for their iconic long, floppy ears and soulful eyes, Basset Hounds were originally bred for hunting and tracking small game, relying on their exceptional sense of smell. While their laid-back and endearing personalities make them wonderful companions, their training can be a bit of a challenge. With a strong instinct to follow scents, these dogs are often more interested in their noses than in obeying commands, which can lead to a stubborn streak during training.
Basset Hounds are independent thinkers, and their focus on scents means they can easily become distracted. However, they respond well to positive reinforcement, especially when food is involved, making treats an essential tool for training. Their love for food and rewards can help keep them engaged and cooperative.
Training Tip
To train a Basset Hound effectively, use high-value treats and keep sessions short and engaging. Patience and consistency are key, as their stubborn nature may require extra effort to maintain their attention and cooperation.
6. Australian Shepherd
The Australian Shepherd, with its boundless energy and remarkable intelligence, might seem like an ideal candidate for easy training. However, their sharp minds can often work against them, making this breed a bit of a challenge to handle. Being one of the smartest dog breeds in the world, Australian Shepherds quickly pick up new commands, but their intelligence also means they can grow bored just as fast. A bored Aussie is more likely to test boundaries or lose interest in training altogether.
Their high energy levels add another layer of complexity. Without engaging and dynamic training sessions, they may become restless or even outsmart their owners during training. Australian Shepherds thrive on mental and physical stimulation, so their training needs to be as energetic and challenging as they are.
Training Tip: To keep an Australian Shepherd engaged, focus on short, frequent training sessions that incorporate movement, toys, and high-value treats. Mixing in activities like fetch or agility training can help burn off excess energy and keep their brilliant minds focused. With the right approach, this clever breed can become an exceptional companion.
7. Bulldog
The Bulldog may appear tough with its muscular build, but this breed is a gentle and affectionate companion. Despite their loving nature, Bulldogs are known for being quite lazy, preferring a cozy spot on the couch to vigorous activity. Their low energy levels, combined with a stubborn streak, make training them a unique challenge.
Historically bred in England for the brutal sport of bull baiting, Bulldogs developed independent thinking skills to survive the arena. While bull baiting has long been outlawed, their strong-willed nature remains, making them less inclined to respond to commands compared to more trainable breeds.
Training Tip
Patience is key when training a Bulldog. Focus on short, engaging sessions and use positive reinforcement with plenty of tasty treats to motivate them. Keeping sessions fun and rewarding can help them work through their hard-headed tendencies and make training more manageable.
Conclusion
Training a dog can be a rewarding experience, but as we’ve seen, certain breeds present unique challenges. Whether it’s the stubborn breeds like the Afghan Hound or the independent dogs like the Siberian Husky, the training process requires patience, persistence, and understanding. These dogs often demand dedicated training and proper socialization to help them thrive as companions. Without enough exercise or mental stimulation, even the most highly intelligent dogs can develop destructive behavior or a bad habit or two.
While these notoriously difficult breeds may take more effort to train, they also bring unique qualities to the dog world, from being natural guard dogs to showing extremely loyal behavior. With basic obedience training and properly trained methods, these dogs can shine as remarkable pets. For families with small children or other dogs, it’s especially important to invest the time and effort to create a balanced, happy environment. With the right approach, even the hardest dogs to train can become loving, well-behaved companions.
Training a dog can be a rewarding yet challenging task, especially with certain breeds known for their stubbornness or intelligence. The seven hardest dog breeds to train, typically including the likes of the Afghan Hound, Basenji, Bulldog, Chow Chow, Borzoi, Fox Terrier, and Rottweiler, require experienced owners who possess patience, consistency, and a deep understanding of canine behavior. While these breeds can be difficult, their challenges often lie in their independent nature or strong-willed personalities. With dedication and the right training approach, even the most challenging breeds can become well-behaved companions, showcasing the profound impact of effective training and owner commitment.