When it comes to choosing the perfect canine companion for your family, opting for a guard dog might seem like a practical choice; however, not all breeds possess the characteristics needed for this role, particularly in a family setting. While loyal and loving, some dogs are simply not cut out for safeguarding your home. Whether it’s due to size, temperament, or instinct, certain breeds may not offer the protection you seek, potentially compromising safety and harmony. Understanding these traits can help you avoid the pitfalls of picking a mismatched pet, ensuring peace of mind for both your loved ones and your furry friend.
When choosing the right dog breed for your family, it’s essential to consider more than just temperament. For those looking for a family-friendly dog with protective instincts, selecting the right guardian breed is crucial. However, some guardian dog breeds—while excellent in their roles as protectors—may not always be the best fit for family environments, particularly with children. Certain breeds, such as giant livestock guardian breeds or mastiff breeds, can pose significant challenges for families due to their size, territorial nature, or high energy levels.
In this article, we’ll explore the worst guardian breeds for families, shedding light on why these dogs might not always be the best choice for households with young children or multiple pets. With warning advice from canine experts like Will Atherton, you’ll better understand which breeds could lead to potential dangers and which might be better suited for experienced dog owners or individuals seeking a more protective dog in a domestic setting.
Worst Guardian Breeds for Families
1. English Bulldog
English Bulldogs are well-regarded for their loyalty and affectionate nature, but they may not be the ideal choice for families seeking a guard dog. While they have a strong territorial instinct due to their history as bull-baiters, their calm and docile demeanor often prevents them from being effective protectors. Bulldogs are generally friendly and gentle with their families and may not show the aggression needed to guard the home or deter intruders.
According to AKC, though Bulldogs can form deep bonds with their families, they can present challenges when it comes to training and socialization. Their stubbornness can make them difficult to train, and without proper guidance, they may develop undesirable behaviors. Bulldogs may also be possessive, especially over food or toys, and require consistent socialization to ensure they interact appropriately with other people and animals. If not properly managed, these traits can lead to issues, particularly in households with young children or frequent visitors.
Challenges for Families
-
Training Difficulties: Bulldogs are known for their strong-willed personalities, which can make them harder to train than other breeds. Their stubbornness often leads to resistance when following commands, making consistent training and patience essential.
-
Territorial Instincts: Bulldogs tend to be fiercely protective of their home and family. However, their territorial nature may lead to aggressive behavior towards strangers or even family members if not properly managed.
-
Health Issues: Bulldogs are prone to various health problems, including respiratory issues due to their brachycephalic (short-nosed) structure. These health concerns can make them less suitable for active households with young children or families seeking a dog that can handle more rigorous activities.
2. Beagle
Beagles are widely loved for their friendly nature and energetic personalities. These dogs make excellent family pets and are known to be great with children, forming strong bonds with their human companions. They’re natural pranksters, always playful and full of life, which makes them a great choice for families seeking an energetic lap dog. Beagles are also relatively easygoing, often enjoying the company of other pets in the house.
However, when it comes to being a guard dog, Beagles fall short. While extremely friendly, their playful nature and strong prey drive mean they’re more likely to chase squirrels than protect the house from intruders. Their love of play, combined with a lack of a “no off switch,” makes them a poor choice for guarding, and they may even find frustrating situations with other pets or humans they don’t know. This breed also tends to bark excessively, adding to the challenges for families who need a quieter home environment.
Challenges for Families
-
Strong Prey Drive: Beagles have a strong hunting instinct, which can lead them to herd children or chase smaller pets, making them a problematic breed for families with multiple animals.
-
Excessive Barking: Their love of vocalizing can be disruptive, especially in homes with young children or guests.
-
Training and Obedience: Beagles can be challenging for novice dog trainers. Their stubborn nature often leads them to resist training, making them more difficult to handle for those without experience in helping fix dogs.
3. Saint Bernard
Saint Bernards are gentle giants, often compared to the gentle golden retriever in terms of their loving nature and calm demeanor. According to Britannica, these big dogs are famous for their rescue work, helping save people from perilous situations in the Swiss Alps. Known for their patient temperament, they are extremely friendly and have a natural instinct to protect their humans. As a result, they are typically a good choice for families looking for a loving companion who enjoys playtime and lounging around on the couch.
However, due to their size, Saint Bernards can pose challenges for families, especially those with small children or limited space. Their massive build makes them difficult to manage, and they can unintentionally knock over kids or pets. While they are typically not aggressive, their size and strength require proper training, or they could accidentally cause harm. For families looking for a lap dog, the Saint Bernard may be a bit too much to handle, especially in smaller homes.
Challenges for Families
-
Size and Strength: These big dogs can be difficult to manage in homes with children or limited space. Their size means they may inadvertently hurt smaller children or pets.
-
Training Needs: While generally gentle, they still require consistent training, especially as their size and strength could lead to accidental harm if they are not properly controlled.
-
Health Concerns: Saint Bernards, like all mastiff breeds, are prone to joint problems and other health issues that may limit their activity levels and make them less suitable for highly active families.
4. Bullmastiff
Bullmastiffs are known for their protective instincts and loyalty, often ranking high among breeds Mr. Atherton recommends for guarding homes. These dogs, which belong to the mastiff family, are extremely powerful and have a natural talent for protecting their families from even intruders. While they are typically calm and affectionate with their owners, their guarding tendencies can sometimes make them one problematic breed for families with young children or frequent visitors.
Their dominant nature, combined with the need for firm training, can make them difficult to handle without the help of an experienced dog trainer. Without consistent socialization, they may view strangers as threats, and this territorial instinct can result in aggression. Although they are great protectors, their lack of socialization can lead to anxiety or fear-based aggression, making them a poor choice for families seeking a more laid-back pet.
Challenges for Families
-
Aggression Toward Strangers: Bullmastiffs are fiercely protective, and without proper socialization, they may become aggressive toward visitors or unfamiliar people.
-
Lack of Socialization: If not properly trained, Bullmastiffs may develop territorial behaviors that make them difficult to manage in public or around new people.
-
Large Size and Strength: As one of the biggest dogs in the mastiff family, their size and strength can make them challenging for families, particularly those with children who may not be able to control them.
5. Cane Corso
The Cane Corso is another mastiff family member known for its protective nature and strength. According to PetMD, this breed is often considered one of the best guard dogs due to its instinct to protect its home and family. While their loyalty and protective traits make them excellent guard dogs, Mr. Atherton highlighted that Cane Corsos requires strong leadership and consistent training to avoid becoming overly aggressive, especially toward strangers. They thrive under a skilled dog trainer’s guidance and can be great family dogs if raised in the right environment.
However, without proper training, Cane Corsos can exhibit dominance and aggression. Their territorial instincts mean they may act aggressively toward unfamiliar people or situations. Cane Corsos also need a lot of exercise, which can be challenging for families with busy lifestyles. Without mental stimulation or physical activity, they can become destructive or develop behavioral problems.
Challenges for Families
-
Aggressive Behavior: Cane Corsos are naturally protective and may become aggressive toward strangers or children if not properly trained and socialized.
-
Territorial: Their strong territorial instincts may lead them to bite children or other pets, especially if they feel threatened by unfamiliar individuals or environments.
-
High Energy: Cane Corsos require extensive physical activity and mental stimulation. Families who are unable to meet these needs may find their dog’s behavior problematic.
6. Russell Terrier
The Russell Terrier is a small but energetic breed known for its lively, independent nature. While they make great companions for active families, their high energy levels and territorial instincts can lead to challenges in multi-pet households. As natural hunters, Russell Terriers may try to herd children or chase after other animals, especially if they have not been properly socialized. Despite their size, they have no off switch when it comes to playtime or protecting their territory.
Russell Terriers are also known to be strong-willed, making training a challenge for families without experience. Their independent streak can lead them to disregard commands, and they may become aggressive toward unfamiliar people or pets. This makes them a poor fit for families who are not willing to dedicate time and effort to consistent training.
Challenges for Families
-
High Energy and Aggression: Russell Terriers are energetic and can become aggressive toward other pets or children. Their high energy requires constant supervision and management.
-
Training Challenges: Known for their independence, Russell Terriers may not always follow commands, making them challenging for families without experience in training dogs.
-
Territorial Instincts: Russell Terriers can be territorial and may bite or guard their space aggressively, making them difficult to manage around new people or animals.
7. Bull Terrier
Bull Terriers are known for their strong, independent personalities and protective instincts. With their muscular build and distinctive head shape, they are often seen as tough, but their loyalty and affection make them a favorite among dog lovers. While they can be a good fit for families with experience handling strong-willed dogs, they are not always the best choice for those with small children or who are inexperienced with dog training.
Challenges for Families
-
Aggression Towards Strangers: Bull Terriers can become protective and aggressive toward unfamiliar people, which makes them unsuitable for families who have frequent visitors or need a dog that can comfortably interact with others.
-
Stubbornness: This breed is extremely independent and can be difficult to train, requiring a skilled dog trainer to help manage their behavior effectively.
-
Challenging for Families: Due to their protective nature and stubborn temperament, Bull Terriers may pose a risk of biting or causing harm to children or guests, making them better suited for experienced dog owners rather than families with young children.
Purina states that Bull Terriers can be aggressive toward strangers, making them one of the worst guard dogs for families who expect an easy-going, protective companion. Their stubbornness and strong prey drive can also lead to challenging behavior, especially if they are not properly trained. Families should be warned that without proper supervision, they could become territorial or even dangerous, especially in the presence of unfamiliar people.
Conclusion
Choosing a guard dog for your family requires careful thought and consideration, especially when looking at guardian breeds. While some dogs—like the Labrador Retriever or Golden Retrievers—make excellent family dogs, others, such as English Bulldogs, Beagles, and certain mastiff breeds, might not be the best fit for family life. These dogs, though protective and loyal, can present challenges in training, behavior, and socialization that could lead to a problematic breed for households without experience.
If you’re seeking a gentle companion for your home, it’s important to evaluate how a breed’s temperament aligns with your family’s needs. Breeds like the friendly Labrador, or even greyhounds with their wagging tails, can provide protection without the risks associated with more aggressive guardian breeds.
By following the right training and finding a dog breed that suits your lifestyle, you can ensure that your home remains safe, peaceful, and full of wagging tails. Sign up for free email alerts from canine experts like Will Atherton to receive cautionary advice that will help you avoid making a decision that could go terribly wrong.
In conclusion, while some dogs possess natural protective instincts, not all breeds are suited for the role of a guard dog, especially within family settings. The seven breeds highlighted may lack the innate territorial or protective traits necessary for effective guarding. They might be too friendly, lack aggression, or require extensive training to overcome their inherent temperament quirks. Families seeking a guard dog should prioritize breeds known for their vigilance, loyalty, and ease of training. It’s essential for families to assess their specific needs and environments, ensuring that the chosen breed aligns with their lifestyle and security goals.