Choosing the perfect canine companion is a decision that should be guided by lifestyle, environment, and personal preferences. Two majestic and popular breeds that often capture the hearts of dog lovers are the Bernese Mountain Dog and the Great Pyrenees. Both breeds boast remarkable qualities, from their impressive physical stature to their loyal and protective nature. However, they each also come with distinct characteristics and care requirements. As you delve into the world of these gentle giants, understanding their differences and similarities can help determine which breed might be the better fit for your home and heart.
When it comes to large, fluffy, and lovable dog breeds, two giants often steal the show: the Bernese Mountain Dog and the Great Pyrenees. Both breeds have a majestic presence, a gentle temperament, and a strong work ethic, but they also have unique differences that make them better suited for different households.
The Bernese Mountain Dog, originally bred for farm work in the Swiss Alps, is known for its tricolor coat, affectionate nature, and loyalty. On the other hand, the Great Pyrenees, a natural livestock guardian from the Pyrenees Mountains, is independent, protective, and calm—qualities that made it an excellent working dog.
But which one is the right fit for you? Should you go for the Bernese Mountain Dog’s playful personality or the Great Pyrenees’ watchful and protective instincts? Let’s break down the key differences between these two large breeds so you can make an informed decision!
Bernese Mountain Dog vs. Great Pyrenees
At first glance, both breeds look strikingly similar, with their large build, thick coats, and gentle demeanor. However, their differences go beyond appearance.
The Bernese Mountain Dog is a people-oriented companion who thrives on affection and companionship. They are social, love being part of the family, and often act like oversized lap dogs. In contrast, the Great Pyrenees is more independent and reserved, bred to guard livestock and make decisions on its own.
They hail from the Swiss Alps and snowy mountains, where it was traditionally used as a farm dog, draft dog, deter predators and cattle herder. Their thick, tri-colored double coat provides excellent insulation against harsh winter conditions, making them well-suited for cold, snowy environments.
Additionally, the Bernese tends to be more trainable due to its eager-to-please attitude, while the Great Pyrenees can be a bit stubborn because of its strong guardian instincts, as per Hills Pet. The Bernese is an excellent choice if you’re looking for a friendly, easygoing and family-friendly dog. If you want a watchful, self-reliant protector, the Great Pyrenees might be a better fit.
|
Origin |
Swiss Alps (Switzerland) – Bred for farm work and pulling carts |
Pyrenees Mountains (France & Spain) – Bred to guard livestock |
|
Size |
23-27.5 inches tall, 70-115 lbs |
25-32 inches tall, 85-160 lbs |
|
Coat & Grooming |
Long, tricolor double coat – Requires frequent brushing to prevent matting |
Thick, white, weather-resistant coat – Requires weekly brushing to manage shedding |
|
Temperament |
Affectionate, social, eager to please, great with families |
Independent, reserved, protective, natural guardian instincts |
|
Trainability |
Easy to train, responsive to commands, eager to please |
Stubborn, requires firm and patient training, independent thinker |
|
Exercise Needs |
Moderate to high – Enjoys active play, hiking, and working tasks |
Moderate – Needs space to roam and enjoys guarding but isn’t highly active |
|
Living Environment |
Thrives in family settings, prefers cool climates, adaptable |
Best suited for large homes with outdoor space, enjoys cool climates |
|
Health Issues |
Prone to hip dysplasia, cancer, joint issues |
Prone to hip dysplasia, joint issues, bloat |
|
Lifespan |
6-8 years (shorter due to health concerns) |
10-12 years (longer lifespan) |
|
Best For |
Families looking for a loving, trainable, and friendly companion |
Owners looking for a protective, independent, and loyal guardian |
Bernese Mountain Dog vs. Great Pyrenees: Size
Both breeds are large dogs, but the Great Pyrenees is bigger and heavier.
-
Bernese Mountain Dog: Typically stands between 23-27.5 inches tall and weighs 70-115 pounds.
-
Great Pyrenees: Slightly larger, standing 25-32 inches tall and weighing 85-160 pounds.
This size difference means Great Pyrenees require more space and are better suited for larger homes with many family members or rural environments. Their sheer strength also makes them harder to control for inexperienced owners. WebMD claims the Bernese Mountain Dog, while still large, is slightly more manageable due to their friendly and trainable temperament.
If you’re considering one of these breeds, make sure you have enough room—both of them need ample space to move around!
Bernese Mountain Dog vs. Great Pyrenees: Personality
Personality is where these two breeds truly differ.
The AKC recognised Bernese Mountain Dog is incredibly affectionate, social, and eager to please when compared to other dogs. They love being around people, thrive in family settings, and are known for their playful and friendly demeanor. They are fantastic with children and other pets, making them one of the best family dogs.
The Great Pyrenees, on the other hand, is calm, independent, and protective. They were bred to guard livestock, which means they have strong territorial instincts and can be aloof with strangers. While they are loyal to their families, they aren’t as cuddly or attention-seeking as the Bernese.
If you want a devoted family companion, Bernese Mountain Dog is the right dog for you. If you need a guardian who will protect your home and family, the Great Pyrenees is the better option.
Bernese Mountain Dog vs. Great Pyrenees: Training and Development
When it comes to training, the Bernese Mountain Dog is the clear winner.
-
PetMD says Bernese Mountain Dogs are eager to learn, making them relatively easy to train. They respond well to positive reinforcement and enjoy tasks like obedience training, therapy work, and agility sports. Crate training is a valuable skill for them, providing them with a safe space while also making house training, travel, and alone time easier. Due to their gentle and sensitive nature, Bernese Mountain Dogs respond best to positive reinforcement and gradual training.
-
Great Pyrenees, however, have a stubborn and independent streak compared to other animals. They were bred to make decisions on their own, meaning they can be more challenging to train. They respond better to firm, patient training rather than forceful commands.
Both breeds need early socialization and consistent training to ensure they grow into well-behaved adults. However, if you’re a first-time dog owner, the Bernese Mountain Dog will likely be easier to train and more eager to follow commands.
Bernese Mountain Dog vs. Great Pyrenees: Health and Maintenance
Both breeds require significant grooming and healthcare, but their needs differ:
-
Bernese Mountain Dogs have a medium-length, thick double coat that sheds year-round. They require regular brushing to keep their fur from matting and excessive shedding under control.
Orvis says the Great Pyrenees have a long, dense coat that helps them withstand cold weather. They are heavy shedders, especially in warm climates, and need frequent brushing to keep their fur clean. It is worth noting that they have a thick, weather-resistant coat that is self-cleaning (similar to how a cat’s fur works). While they do shed heavily, they are low maintenance and don’t require frequent baths and only need weekly brushing to manage loose fur.
Health-wise, both breeds are prone to hip and elbow dysplasia and eye disorders, but the Bernese Mountain Dog has a higher risk of certain health issues like cancer, which unfortunately affects their lifespan.
Regular vet checkups, a balanced diet, high quality dog food and exercise are essential for keeping both breeds healthy.
Bernese Mountain Dog vs. Great Pyrenees: Life Expectancy
One of the biggest drawbacks of owning a Bernese Mountain Dog is its shorter lifespan.
-
Bernese Mountain Dog: 6-8 years (prone to cancer and joint issues).
-
Great Pyrenees Dog: 10-12 years (more resilient but still prone to joint problems).
Purina claims the Great Pyrenees, one of the best guardian dogs, generally lives longer, making them a better choice for owners looking for a long-term companion. However, both breeds require proper care, moderate exercise, nutrition, and regular veterinary checkups to maximize their lifespan.
Conclusion
Choosing between a Bernese Mountain Dog and a Great Pyrenees ultimately comes down to your lifestyle and what you’re looking for in a dog.
-
Pick a Bernese Mountain Dog if you want a loving, friendly, and trainable companion who thrives on social interaction and vigorous exercise. They are great for families and first-time dog owners who want an affectionate, people-oriented pet.
-
Choose a Great Pyrenees if you need an independent, protective, and self-reliant dog who will guard your home and family. They are better suited for experienced owners who understand their strong-willed nature.
Both breeds are gentle giants with unique personalities, making them great family pets. So whichever you choose, you’ll end up with a loyal and loving companion. Just be prepared for shedding, training, and lots of outdoor adventures!
In comparing the Bernese Mountain Dog and the Great Pyrenees, both breeds offer unique characteristics that may appeal to different owners. The Bernese Mountain Dog is known for its friendly nature and adaptability, making it well-suited for families and those seeking a sociable companion. Conversely, the Great Pyrenees is renowned for its protective instinct and independence, ideal for those needing a reliable watchdog. Ultimately, the choice between the two depends on individual preferences and lifestyle. Evaluating your living conditions, activity level, and personal preferences will guide you to the breed that best aligns with your needs and expectations.